Peter Oltchick (peteroltchick.com) is the award-winning co-author of Football for Fun: The Story of Coach Stewart “Fergie” Ferguson. John Burroughs (Midwest Book Review) writes: “A simply fascinating read from start to finish.” Peter has written for the online magazine Suite101 and is the author of Clean Clara, a children’s picture book celebrating friendship. He loves to visit schools for customized classroom and library programs. Peter is an accomplished marketing and business development thought leader, an advocate of a positive, inclusive youth sports culture, and would welcome a shot to compete in a Connect 4 championship down the road. He is thrilled to be co-hosting Why Not Us?! and is an unapologetic optimist when it comes to his sports fandom—yes, including the NY Jets (one of these years?!).

Scott Greenhut is a lifelong New Yorker who never had to choose his teams — the Mets, Giants, Knicks, and Rangers were handed down from his father like a blessing (or a curse?) He is still nostalgic for MSG's color-coded seat sections, the knishes at Giants Stadium that served double duty as handwarmers in December, and the introduction of the K corner soon after Doc Gooden’s arrival in Queens. In his professional career, Scott has spent over 20 years navigating the fintech world, currently as SVP of Business Development for Prove. He, too, is thrilled to be co-hosting Why Not US?!, a podcast built for fans who’ve been through it all and somehow still believe.